Reduction of indicator and pathogenic microorganisms by psychrophilic
anaerobic digestion in swine slurries.
1 Caroline Côté *, 2 Daniel I. Massé and 3 Sylvain Quessy
1 Research and development institute for the agri-environment, 3300 Sicotte, Saint-Hyacinthe,
2 Dairy and Swine Research and Development Centre, Research Branch, Agriculture and Agri-
Food Canada, Lennoxville, Quebec, Canada, J1M 1Z3.
C Faculty of veterinary medicine, University of Montreal, C.P. 5000, 3200 Sicotte, Saint-
* Corresponding author. Tel.: 450-778-6522; Fax : 450-778-6539; E-mail address:
The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficiency of a low temperature anaerobic treatment to
reduce viable populations of indicator microorganisms (total coliforms, Escherichia coli
) and selected
pathogens (Salmonella, Yersinia enterocolitica, Crytosporidium
) in swine slurries. Experiments
were carried out in 4 40-L Sequencing Batch Reactors (SBRs). Experimental results indicated that
anaerobic digestion of swine manure slurry at 20oC for 20 days in an intermittently fed SBR: 1)
reduced indigenous populations of total coliforms by 97.94 to 100 %; 2) reduced indigenous
populations of Escherichia coli
by 99.67 to 100 %; 3) resulted in undetectable levels of indigenous
strains of Salmonella
, and Giardia
: anaerobic treatment, psychrophilic, swine slurry, methane production, pathogens
Canada is one of the most important pork producing country in the world. Over the past 20 years, the
swine industry has evolved from a diversified to a specialized and intensified production system. It has
grown more than 400% since 1982. Rapid growth has led to difficulties in the management of swine
manure, resulting in serious environmental concerns. The environmental and social issues are presently
the greatest challenge faced by Canada's fast growing hog industry. As a result, the industry cannot
take advantage of the increasing international market opportunities for pork meat. In some areas, hog
producers are forced to limit production due to environmental and social issues.
Environmental problems related to manure management include air, water and soil pollution and health
hazards caused by the presence of zoonotic pathogens in the manure. As a matter of consequence,
there is an urgent need for cost-effective biotechnologies to address the above environmental issues.
Animal wastes can contain organisms capable of causing infectious disease in humans (Cole et al.,
1999). In swine production, microorganisms of interest include members of the Enterobacteriacae
, and Yersinia enterocolitica
) and the protozoan Cryptosporidium
the environment, coliforms and Escherichia coli
are used as fecal contamination indicators.
Coliforms and Escherichia coli
Coliforms and Escherichia coli
are natural constituents of the intestinal tract of humans and animals.
They are frequently used as a faecal contamination indicators in the environment, E.coli
effective. The majority of intestinal E. coli
strains are harmless commensals. However, some strains
possess virulence factors that can lead to human infection (Nataro et al., 1998). There are at least four
categories of recognized diarrheagenic E. coli
: 1) enterotoxigenic (ETEC), a cause of travelers' and
infant diarrhea in developing countries; 2) enteroinvasive (EIEC), cause of watery diarrhea; 3)
enteropathogenic (EPEC), responsible for infant diarrhea, and 4) enterohemorrhagic (EHEC), the
cause of hemorrhagic colitis (HC) and hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS) (Nataro et al., 1998).
O157 is a member of this last group frequently associated with illness in human. It
has been isolated from samples of pigs rectal faeces (Chapman et al., 1997). However, isolates were
not typical of strains causing infections in humans. In Quebec, non-O157 pig isolates possessing
virulence factors implicated in human infection has been reported (Desrosiers et al., 2001).
The genus Salmonella
comprises more than 2400 serotypes, all potentially pathogenic for humans
(Bopp et al., 1999). Salmonella
usually causes an intestinal infection characterized by diarrhea, fever,
and abdominal cramps that often lasts one week or longer. The prevalence of Salmonella
finished swine was estimated at 5.2 % in Quebec (Letellier et al., 1999). Pigs can shed Salmonella
into the environment without showing any signs of the disease (Gray et al., 1996; Ekperigin et al.,
causes illness characterized by fever, abdominal pain, and diarrhea in humans.
In Quebec, 80% of swine herds were found positive to Yersinia enterocolitica
(Pilon et al., 2000).
Serogroup O:3, the most common strain associated with disease in people, was found in 93.5 % of
the isolates recovered in this study. Pigs are considered to be the most common source of human
Cryptosporidium spp. and Giardia spp
spp. and Giardia
spp. are protozoan pathogens causing diarrhoeal illness in humans
and a wide range of vertebrates. Cryptosporidiosis is self-limiting in healthy subjects, but can be life-
threatening in highly immunocompromised patients. There is no effective treatment for
The majority of individuals infected with Giardia
are asymptomatic. Symptomatic individuals can
experience nausea and watery diarrhea. Humans, dogs, cats and beaver are recognized as the principal
reservoirs of Giardia,
is common in humans and calves. However, pigs are
now recognized as an important reservoir (Xiao et al., 1994; Morgan, 1999). In Canada, Giardia
were identified in four out of six hog operations with an overall prevalence of 9 %
and 11 % for Cryptosporidium
(Olson et al., 1997).
Few studies have been carried out to assess the efficiency of anaerobic digestion to remove pathogens
from organic wastes. Bendixen (1994) indicated that thermophilic temperature destroyed pathogens,
while mesophilic temperature had no effect on reduction of pathogens. Kumar et al. (1999)
investigated the survival of some pathogens in anaerobic batch reactors. Escherichia coli
survived up to 20 and 10 days at temperatures of 20 and 35 C respectively. The
survival of Salmonella
Typhi increased from 20 to 35 days when the solid contents was increased
form 9% to 15%. Duarte et al. (1992) have been successful in using AD at 37 and 54.9 C to
remove Salmonella, Streptococci
and coliforms from swine slurry. Kearny et al. 1993 investigated the
efficiency of full scale AD reactor operated at 28 C to remove pathogenic bacteria. Escherichia coli,
Typhimurium, Yersinia enterocolitica, Listeria monocytogenes
and Campylobacter jejuni
partially removed during the treatment period. There is no information in the literature on the
efficiency of AD process for the removal of Cryptosporidium
Massé et al. (1996; 1997a; 1997b) evaluated the feasibility of using psychrophilic anaerobic digestion
(PAD) at 20 oC in non-mixed and intermittently fed SBRs1 to stabilize and deodorize swine manure
slurry while recovering biogas for energy. Experimental results indicated that PAD of swine manure
slurry in SBRs was technically feasible to stabilize and deodorize swine manure slurry. The process
was very stable and not affected by high concentration of volatile acids (VA) and ammonia nitrogen.
It produced high quality biogas and provided excellent settling conditions to retain high
concentrations of anaerobic bacteria in the system.
There is few information in the literature on the efficiency of low temperature anaerobic process (15 –
20 oC) to remove pathogens. Therefore the objective of this study was to evaluate the efficiency of
the psychrophilic anaerobic digestion process in a sequencing batch reactor to reduce viable
populations of indicator microorganisms (total coliforms, Escherichia Coli)
and indigenous pathogens
(Salmonella, Yersinia enterocolitica, Crytosporidium
) in swine slurries from different sources.
Figure 1 is a schematic of the bench scale SBRs used in this study. Four 42 L plexiglas digesters were
located in a temperature controlled room (20°C). The sludge volume at the beginning of a cycle was
21 L. SBRs were mixed 5 minutes every morning by recirculating the biogas. Wet tip gas meters
were used to measure the daily biogas production. Manure slurries were obtained from manure
transfer tanks and long term storages located on commercial growing-finishing, nursery and maternity
hog operations. The samples of manure collected on commercial farms, were send to the Agriculture
and Agri-food Canada laboratory and used to feed to the laboratory scale digestors within 48 hours
period. Feed and react period length of 2 weeks each (total treatment cycle length of 4 weeks) had
tc = tf + tr + tsd
where tc represent the total treatment cycle time, tf represent the duration of the feed period, tr
represents the duration of the react period and tsd the duration of the settle and draw periods. Final
reaction and settling occurred at the end of the react period. Draw times were less than one-half hour.
A mixed liquor sample was withdrawn from each SBR at the beginning of the experiment and once a
week during each experimental procedure. At the end of each experiment, after the sedimentation
period, additional samples were withdrawn from the supernatant. The samples were analysed for pH,
alkalinity, solids, VFAs, total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN), ammonia nitrogen, total chemical oxygen
demand (TCOD), and Soluble COD (SCOD). Biogas production was monitored daily and its
composition was analyzed weekly. SCOD was determined by analyzing the supernatant of centrifuged
slurry. The pH, alkalinity, and solids were determined using standard methods (APHA, 1992). TKN
and ammonia nitrogen were determined using an auto-analyzer. VFAs and biogas composition were
Sludge samples were aseptically taken from each SBRs before feeding to verify the presence of
coliforms, Escherichia coli
, Yersinia enterocolitica
, and Giardia
Microbiological analysis of raw manure slurry was made within 24 hours before feeding the SBRs. At
the end of each treatment cycle, after the sedimentation period, additional samples were taken from
the supernatant for microbiological analysis.
Coliforms and Escherichia coli
were counted by plating 3M Petrifilms with 1 ml of intact or diluted
liquid hog manure. Dilutions were made with phosphate- buffered saline. Pink colonies producing gas
were counted as coliforms, and blue ones with gas were counted as Escherichia coli
In order to verify the presence of Escherichia coli
O:157, 25 g of the sample were incubated in 225
ml of modified Tryptic soy broth with novobiocin for 24 h at 42oC. One loopful of the culture was
inoculated onto modified sorbitol MacConkey agar containing tellurite, cefixime, and cefsulodin.
Suspect (colorless) colonies were used to inoculate purple broth base with cellobiose. Biochemical
assays (indole, MR, VP, citrate) were used to confirm the identification of cellobiose negative
was detected by incubating 25 g of the samples in 225 ml of nutrient broth (Difco
laboratories, Detroit, Mich.) overnight at 37oC. Following this pre-enrichment step, one ml of
nutrient broth was incubated into 9 ml of Tetrathionate Brilliant Green broth (BBL Microbiology
Systems, Cockeysville, Md) overnight at 37oC. One loopful of the TBG culture were inoculated onto
a Brilliant Green Sulfa agar (Difco) containing 20 ìg/ml of novobiocine (Sigma chemicals Co., St.
Louis, Mo.) and incubated for 24 to 48 hours at 37oC. Lactose negative colonies were tested
biochemically (triple sugar iron and urea hydrolysis) and identification was confirmed by API
processing (Biomerieux, Ville St-Laurent, Quebec).
For the detection of Yersinia enterocolitica
, ten grams of samples were incubated in 90 ml of
phosphate-buffered saline containing sorbitol (2 %) and biliary salts (0.15 %) at 4oC for 21 days.
Isolation was carried out on Yersinia
agar base (cefsulodin-irgasan-novobiocin agar, Oxoid) with an
incubation time of 24 to 48 h at 28oC. Typical colonies were biochemically tested (Triple Sugar Iron
and urea hydrolysis). API testing (Biomerieux) was done in order to complete the identification.
The detection of Cryptosporidium
was done using Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays
(ELISA). Prospect Cryptosporidium
microplate assay and Prospect Giardia
(Alexon-Trend, Inc., Ramsey, MN) were performed according to manufacturer's instructions.
Organic Loading Rates and Cycle Operation
Organic loading rates that are given in Table 1
are based on the amount of COD fed to the volume
of sludge present at the start of a cycle (21L). The loading equation is as follow:
where LS,f is loading rate based on initial sludge volume and feed time; Vf is the volume of feed; C is
the COD concentration in the feed; VS is the volume of sludge at the beginning of a cycle; and tf is the
Table 1 gives the experimental design used in this study. It identifies for each treatment cycle the
source of manure sample, the organic loading rate and the volume of manure slurry fed to each
bioreactors. Digestion of swine manure slurry no. 40 was repeated two times simultaneously in two
The reactors were fed at different organic loading rates due to physical constrain. Some of the
manure slurry were so diluted that the bioreactor were not large enough to receive sufficient volume
to reach the design organic loading rate of 2.00 g COD / L-d.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 2 gives the physico-chemical characteristics of the swine manure slurries collected on 20
commercial swine farms. The characteristics of the manure slurry fed to the bioreactors were highly
variable. Total solids, total COD and total VFAs contents varied from 1.1 to 15.2% (weight basis),
12.9 to 96.3 mg/L and 0.4 to 34 mg/L respectively.
Sludge samples taken in SBRs before the beginning of the experiment were free of coliforms,
Escherichia coli, Salmonella, Yersinia enterocolitica, Crytosporidium
, and Giardia.
O:157 and Yersinia enterocolitica
were not found in any sample of raw manure
slurries. Table 3a shows the types and concentrations of indicator microorganisms and pathogens
found in manure slurries before the treatment. Total coliforms counts varied from 0 to 3.3 x 106
CFU/g. Initial Escherichia coli
populations were also highly variable, ranging from 0 to 2.6 x 106
were detected in 7, 4, and 2 samples respectively.
The treatment resulted in undetectable levels of coliforms in 9 out of 20 manure samples. One liquid
swine manure didn't contain coliforms before the treatment. In the remaining 10 samples, a reduction
of 1.62 - 4.23 log CFU/ml was observed (97.94 - 99.99 % reduction). Olsen (1988) observed the
impacts of mesophilic (35oC) anaerobic filter treatment on indigenous coliforms populations in liquid
pig manure. He reported an average reduction of 1.1 and 1.0 log CFU/ml for hydraulic retention
Undetectable levels of Escherichia coli
were observed in 15 out of 20 samples of swine manure
slurries after anaerobic digestion, including one raw liquid swine manure free of this bacteria and
sample no. 40 used two times. In the five remaining samples, a reduction of 2.48 - 4.16 log CFU/ml
was observed (99.67 - 99.99 % reduction). Juris et al. (1996) observed similar results at higher
temperature. He reported a complete elimination of Escherichia coli
EC 5 strain after a 18 days
anaerobic mesophilic (35-37oC) digestion of pig slurry in a 800 l fermenter. Kumar et al. (1999) used
an ampicillin-resistant strain of Escherichia coli
to study the persistence of this bacteria in cattle dung
slurry during anaerobic digestion. The survival was 25 days at room temperature (18-25oC) and 15
In the present study, psychrophilic anaerobic digestion resulted in undetectable levels of Salmonella
in the seven swine manure slurries positive for this bacteria. Kumar et al. (1999) reported a longer
survival of artificially added streptomycin-resistant strain of Salmonella
Typhi in cattle dung slurry
during anaerobic digestion. He observed a complete elimination of this bacteria on the fifteenth day at
35oC and on the twentyfifth day at room temperature. The survival time of Salmonella
increased when the solid contents of the digester were elevated from 9 % to 15 %. The mean decimal
reduction time (T90) of Salmonella
during a full scale mesophilic anaerobic digestion was 34.5 days
according to Kearny et al. (1993).
Psychrophilic anaerobic digestion destroyed Cryptosporidium
present in 4 and 2 samples
of liquid swine manure respectively. This is the first report on the impact of psychrophilic anaerobic
Temperature and retention time are decisive factors for indicator organisms and pathogens survival
during anaerobic digestion of effluents. According to Olsen et al. (1987) hygienization similar to
anaerobic thermophilic treatment is obtained at mesophilic temperatures by increasing retention time.
Kumar et al. (1999) observed a faster elimination of Escherichia coli
at 35oC than at
room temperature during anaerobic digestion of cattle slurry. Salmonella
and Listeria monocytogenes
also declined more rapidly at 17oC than at 4oC during
anaerobic digestion of cattle slurry (Kearny et al., 1993). It appears that under the conditions of this
experiment, retention time of 28 days at 20oC was sufficient to ensure a stabilization of the liquid
It is important to note that in most reported experiments, only one source of manure slurry was used.
According to Olsen et al. (1987) decimation times of pathogens and indicator microorganisms were
not influenced by the type of slurry (cattle or pig). However, no data were available with different
sources of slurry for a specific animal specie. Our results have shown the effectiveness of the
psychrophilic anaerobic digestion with swine manure slurry from different sources.
Many experiments concerning the impact of anaerobic digestion on indicator and pathogenic
microorganisms have been made by inoculating manure slurries with laboratory or antibiotic-resistant
strains. This last approach is useful since the strains can be selected on agar containing antibiotics
after the treatment. According to Olsen et al. (1987) laboratory strains can be less resistant than
coliforms indigenous to the slurry. On the other hand, Abdul et al. (1985) observed a longer
persistence of antibiotic-resistant strains of Escherichia coli
compared to sensitive isolates during
anaerobic digestion of pig slurry at 37oC. The use of natural liquid swine manure slurries permitted us
to confirm the effectiveness of the psychrophilic anaerobic digestion on indigenous microorganisms.
Tappouni (1984) demonstrated in laboratory studies that the maximum biogas production during
semi-continuous digestion at a hydraulic retention time of 7.5 days corresponded to an increase effect
in reducing the numbers of Salmonella
spp. This decline was correlated with increased volatils fatty
acids and a decrease in pH. However, concentrations in the range of 2000 mg/l can inhibit
biomethagenesis (Winter, 1984). It is then important to reach volatils fatty acids levels permitting the
destruction of pathogens without affecting biomethagenesis.
Figures 2 and 3 give the acetic acid and total volatile fatty acid (TVFA) profile for each treatment
cycle. Acetic and TVFA accumulated in the SBR during the fill period and the early stage of the
react period. Similar profiles were obtained for propionic and butyric acids. For each treatment cycle
the volatile fatty acids were completely utilized at the end of the react period. From these results it
can be concluded that the SBRs were very stable at these loading rates and operating conditions.
Overall Performance of the digesters
The biogas produced in test runs 1 to 5 was of high quality with a methane concentration that
generally exceeded 70%. Table 5 gives the effluent pH for each treatment cycle. All SBRs
maintained pH between 7.6 and 8.1 . The pH decreased slightly during the feed period due to TVFA
accumulation and increased slightly during the react period due to VA utilization. The pH range was
appropriate for microorganisms growth and process stability.
Psychrophilic anaerobic digestion in sequencing batch reactors successfully treated raw swine manure
slurries from different sources. It removed the indigenous populations of Salmonella
, and Giardia
. Natural populations of indicator microorganisms (Escherichia coli
and coliforms) were reduced by 97.94 to 100 %. It can be considered as an effective method for
eliminating indigenous pathogens and reducing indicator organisms populations in liquid swine
manure slurries varying in their physico-chemical and microbiological properties.
This project was financially supported by the Livestock environmental initiative and the Fédération
des producteurs de porcs du Québec. The technical support by Katline Guay, Louise Beausoleil,
Louise Lessard, L. Masse, and D. Deslauriers are appreciated.
APHA 1992. Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater, 18th. ed. American
Public Health Association, Washington, DC.
Bendixen, H.J. 1994. Safeguards against pathogens in Danish biogas plants. Wat. Sci. Tech. Vol. 30,
Bopp, C. A., F. W. Brenner, J. G. Wells , and N. A. Stockbine. 1999. Escherichia
. p. 459-474. In
P. R. Murray, E. J. Baron, M. A. Pfaller, F. C. Tenover, and R. H. Yolken
(ed.) Manual of clinical microbiology. ASM Press, Washington, D.C.
Chapman, P.A., C.A. Siddons, A.T. Cerdan Malo and M.A. Harkin. 1997. A 1-year study of
Escherichia coli O157 in cattle, sheep, pigs and poultry. Epidemiol. Infect. Vol. 119, pp. 245-250.
Cole, D. J., V. R. Hill, F. J. Humenik, and M. D. Sobsey. 1999. Health, safety, and environmetnal
concerns of farm animal wastes. Occupational medicine: Sate of the art reviews. Vol. 14, No. 2, pp.
Desrosiers, A., J. M. Fairbrother, R. P. Johnson, C. Desautels, A. Letellier and S. Quessy. 2001.
Phenotypic and genotypic characterization of Escherichia coli
verotoxin-producing isolates from
humans and pigs. J. Food Prot. Vol. 64, No. 12, pp. 1904-1911.
Duarte, E.A., Mendes, B. and Oliveira, J.S. 1992. Removal of salmonella, Streptococci
in pig breeding effluent by anaerobic mesophilic digestion. Wat. Sci. Tech. Vol. 26, No. 9-
Ekperigin, H. E., and K. V. Nagaraja. 1998. Salmonella
. Vet. Clin. North Am. Vol. 14, No. 1, pp.
Gray, J. T., and P. J. Fedorka-Cray. 1996. Salmonellosis in swine: a review of significant areas
affecting the carrier sate, pp. 80-103. In Proceedings of the first international symposium on ecology
of Salmonella in pork production. Ames, Iowa.
Juris, P., F. Toth, A. Laukova, P. Plachy, P. Dubinsky, and J. Sokol. 1996. Survival of model
bacterial strains and helminth eggs in the course of mesophilic anaerobic digestion of pig slurry. Vet.
Kearny, E.T., Larkin, M.J., Frost, J.P. and P.N. Levett. 1993. Survival of pathogenic bacteria during
mesophillic anaerobic digestion of animal waste. J. App. Bacteriol. Vol. 75, pp. 215-219
Kumar, R., Gupta, M.K. and Kanwar, S.S., 1999. Fate of bacterial pathogens in cattle dung slurry
subjected to anaerobic digestion. World Journal of Microbiology & Biotechnology. Vol. 15, pp. 335-
Massé, D.I., Patni, N.K., Droste, R.L., and Kennedy, K.J. 1996. Operation strategies for
psychrophilic anaerobic digestion of swine manure slurry in sequencing batch reactors. Can. J. Civ.
Massé, D.I., Droste, R.L., Kennedy, K.J., and Patni, N.K. 1997a. Potential for the psychrophilic
anaerobic treatment of swine manure slurry in sequencing batch reactors. Can. Agricul. Engin. J., Vol.
Massé, D.I. and R.L. Droste, 1997b. Microbial interaction during anaerobic treatment of swine
manure slurry in a sequencing batch reactor. Can. Agricul. Engin. J. Vol. 39, No. 1, pp. 35-41.
Morgan, U. M., J. r. Buddle, A. Armson, A Elliot, and R. C. A. Thompson. 1999. Molecular and
biological characterization of Cryptosporidium
in pigs. Aust. Vet. J. Vol. Vol. 77, No. 1, pp. 44-47.
Nataro, J. P., and J. B. Kaper. 1998. Diarrheagenic Escherichia coli
. Clin. Microbiol. Rev. Vol. 11,
Olson, J. E., H. E. Larsen. 1987. Bacterial decimation times in anaerobic digestions of animal slurries.
Olson, J. E. 1988. Studies on the reduction of pathogenic and indicator bacteria in liquid pig manure
treated by sedimentation and anaerobic filter digestion for methane generation. Biol. Wastes. Vol. 24,
Olson, M. E., C. L. Thorlakson, L. Deselliers, D. W. Morck, and T. A. McAllister. 1997. Giardia and
Cryptosporidium in canadian farm animals. Vet. Parasitol. Vol. 68, pp. 375-381.
Tappouni, Y. A. 1984. The fate of Salmonella
in anaerobic digestion. PhD Thesis. University college,
Winter, J., and F. X. Wildenauer. 1984. Comparison of volatile acid turnover during improved
digestion of sewage sludge, cattle manure, and piggery wastes. Third european congress of
biotechnology, Munchen, Germany. Weinheim. Vol. 3, pp. 81-87.
Xiao, L., R. P. Herd, G. L. Bowman. 1994. Prevalence of Cryptosporidium and Giardia infections on
two Ohio pig farms with different management systems. Vet. Parasitol. Vol. 52, pp. 331-336.
OWNER’S MANUAL 12 Bottle Thermoelectric Wine Cooler MODEL: AW-121E Please read and save these instructions. PARTS LIST TROUBLESHOOTING Many common wine refrigerator problems can be easily solved, saving you the cost of a possible service call. Try the suggestions below to see if you can solve your problem before PROBLEM POSSIBLE • The circuit breaker may
Eesti ravimistatistika 2006-2009, lk 30-34 Estonian Statistics on Medicines 2006-2009, pp. 30-34 Diabeediravimite kasutamine Eestis Use of Drugs used in Diabetes Endocrinologist, doctor of medicine, Endocrinology Estonia has not been left untouched by the world-puutumata jäänud ka Eesti. See kajastub wide epidemic of diabetes. It is reflected in the süstitavate ja suukaudset