Survey of antibiotics residues in honey on the swiss market p. edder, c. corvi service de protection de la consommation, 22 quai ernest-ansermet, ch-1211 genève 4, switzerland
SURVEY OF ANTIBIOTICS RESIDUES IN HONEY ON THE SWISS MARKET
P. EDDER, D. ORTELLI, C. CORVI
Service de Protection de la Consommation, 22 Quai Ernest-Ansermet, CH-1211 Genève 4, Switzerland
5. SURVEY OF ANTIBIOTICS RESIDUES IN COMMERCIAL HONEYS
The European and American foulbrood are bacterial diseases extremely
dangerous for bees, able to destroy completely and rapidly an apiary.
Furthermore, these bacteria can propagate very easily to other bee-hives and
presents a very high danger for honey producers.
Antibiotics such as streptomycin, tetracyclines and sulfonamides are often
used in bee-keeping as preventive or therapeutic treatment to protect apiary. Analytical methods have been developed to monitor the presence of antibiotic
362 (72 %)
residues in honey. Rapid screening is performed with the Charm II test and the
quantitative measurements of streptomycin, tetracycline and sulfonamide
residues are done by HPLC. In case of residue levels higher than MRL a
The detailed results of a survey of around 500 honeys are presented and show
a high number of positive cases, but also a lot of honeys with residue
concentrations above the MRL's and sometimes with large overtakings.
Honey with sulfonamide residue
The legislation varies considerably from a country to another and antibiotic
therapy is authorised in some countries, but absolutely prohibited in others like
in Switzerland. However, some MRL's have been fixed in Switzerland for
imported honeys. There are no MRL’s in the UE.
Honey with tetracyclines residue
Screening with Charm II Test for
Streptomycine, Tetracyclines, Sulfonamides
For sulfonamides a previous hydrolysis step is performed
Positive samples with Charm II Test
HPLC specific analysis
Honey with streptomycin residue
Typical residues according to the honey origin
Positive samples with residue > MRL
Confirmation with LC/MS/MS
Sulfonamides 80 to 90% of sulfonamides are bound to sugars and an hydrolysis step before extraction
is absolutely necessary in order to obtain good recoveries.
Para-aminobenzoic acid (PABA), a natural substance, interfers with the Charm test
screening method and creates a lot of false positives. PABA is also able to be derivatised by the fluram and become fluorescent. Furthermore, PABA interfers in the confirmation HPLC method. Generally, PABA elutes near sulfamethazine.
Asulam, used as an herbicide, has a chemical structure like a sulfonamide.
¾ No results for honey from Asia or Oceania, because only mixtures with
Residues can be found in fields and contaminate honey. Moreover, sulfanilamide is
European or American honey are sold on the Swiss market.
In some mixture, origin is very difficult to know and only continental
Sometimes LC with fluorescence detection is not enough selective and LC/MS/MS confirmation is necessary
¾ Sometimes, the residues found are not due to an antibiotic therapy, but are
the result of an illegal mixture with cheaper foreign honey
¾ Analysis of antibiotic residues is difficult and classical methods with
LC/fluorescence have some selectivity problems. However these methods can be used for routine purposes, but results with residues higher than MRL must be confirmed by LC/MS/MS.
¾ In most of countries, e.g. U.E., there is a lack in the legislation concerning
antibiotic bee therapy and residues in honey. Therefore, antibiotics are often used and residues frequently found in honey. Sometimes, very high concentrations (above 1 mg/kg) are observed.
SA=sulfanilamide; STZ=sulfathiazole, SDD=sulfadimidine;
Tetracyclines,Charm II test gives good results with a few false positives results.
The selectivity of the HPLC-fluorescence methods are often very poor. The MRL (20
g/kg) could be difficult to reach. Complementary LC/MS/MS analysis is needed.
 A. Kaufmann, B. Pacciarelli, A. Prijic, B. Ryser, S. Roth, Travaux de chimie
alimentaire et d’hygiène, 90 (1999) 167-176
Charm II test gives good results with a few false positives results.
 P. Edder, A. Cominoli, C. Corvi, J. Chrom A., 830 (1999) 345-351
The HPLC fluorescence method is time consuming and need an extensive sample handling.
A Case of Interstitial Pneumonia suspected to be due to SpirulinaTM Kitazawa Y, Saito F, Tomino A and Fujii H Department of Emergency and Critical Care Medicine, Kansai Medical University Hirakata Hospital, Hirakata-city, Osaka, JAPAN Objective : A 59 years old male with a complaint of dyspnea consulted us. The laboratory test on admission included leukocytosis, positive CRP, negative
S A F E T Y D A T A S H E E T C A F FE IN E C IT R A T E 1 . I D E N T I FI C A T I O N O F T H E S U B ST A N C E /P R E P A R A T I O N A N D T H E C O M P A N Y : P R O D U C T N A M E : C H EM I C A L N A M E 2 : 1,3,7-Trimethyl-1,2,6-tetrahydropurine, 2-hydroxy-1,2,3-propantricarbonic acid (1:1) P A R T N o .: S U P P L IE R : J M Loveridge plcSouthbrook Road, Southampt